Do You Need a Separate Salad Dressing Shaker?
A dedicated dressing bottle earns its place only if you want its measuring marks and pouring lid. Here is who should consider OXO’s large 1.5-cup shaker and who can keep using a suitable jar.
If you make salad dressing often, a dedicated shaker is worth considering when you want to measure, mix, and pour from the same bottle. The OXO Good Grips Salad Dressing Shaker adds printed scales and a lever-operated pouring lid to that routine. Those are useful conveniences, but they are not a reason to replace a suitable jar that already works for you.
The version here is the large, 1.5-cup shaker in black, sold as one unit, model 1188500. It is not the smaller Little Salad Dressing Shaker or a set.
View the large black OXO Salad Dressing Shaker on Amazon
What you gain over a plain jar
Measurements on the bottle
The cup, ounce, and milliliter markings give you a way to measure liquid ingredients directly in the vessel. That is the clearest reason to consider it if your current jar has no scale and you regularly reach for a separate measuring cup. These are printed measuring guides, not a claim of precision.
A removable top for filling
The top unscrews to expose a wide opening for ingredients. Consider how that compares with the container you already use: a wide-mouth jar may already do this part of the job perfectly well.
A lid designed for pouring
The lever opens and closes the pouring opening. If you would rather pour dressing through a spout than take a jar lid off each time, this is the feature to weigh most heavily. The product photos show the mechanism; they do not establish how every dressing will pour.
The main trade-off: another lid to clean
A dedicated bottle adds something to store, and its pouring lid gives you more detail to clean than a simple jar lid. OXO lists the shaker as dishwasher safe. Even so, cleanup should be part of the buying decision, especially if you prefer containers with very simple lids.
Capacity matters, too. Choose the 1.5-cup version only if it suits the batches you normally make, and check the space where you plan to keep it. Do not buy the large version merely because it is the one pictured here.
Who should buy it—and who can skip it
- Consider it if homemade dressing is a regular habit, your current container lacks measurements, and you specifically want a pouring spout.
- Keep your jar if you already have a suitable food-safe container with a secure lid, are happy with how you measure and serve, and do not want another specialized kitchen item.
- Skip it for now if you rarely make dressing or have no clear complaint about your existing setup.
The buying question is simple: would you use the markings and pouring lid often enough to justify storing and cleaning this bottle? If yes, this OXO is a focused option. If not, keep the jar and leave the extra bottle off your shopping list.
Check the single black 1.5-cup OXO shaker on Amazon
Where to buy
OXO Good Grips Salad Dressing Shaker — 1188500, Black, large 1.5 cup, one unit
You make salad dressing often and want measuring marks and a pouring lid in one bottle.
Keep in mind: Adds a specialized bottle and pouring lid to store and clean. Keep a suitable jar if it already meets your needs. Not a bag-transport guarantee.
View on Amazon: OXO Good Grips Salad Dressing Shaker — 1188500, Black, large 1.5 cup, one unit (opens in a new tab)